Bestseller Lists Are Scam Credentials
And yes, I list them too--- here’s why.
Let’s get honest about something everyone in the writing world knows but rarely says out loud: most “bestseller” lists are total scam credentials.
And if you’re a ghostwriter, author, or publishing hopeful, you deserve to understand how this game works before you beat yourself up for not hitting a title that doesn’t mean what you think it means.
Let’s break down what “bestseller” really means.
You’d think it would be the book that’s selling the most, right? Not quite.

Amazon bestsellers reset hourly and are based on category. If your book sells 20 copies in the “Architecture of Religion” niche at 2am on a Tuesday, congrats--- you’re a bestseller! On top of that, USA Today and Wall Street Journal lists are pay-to-play in many cases.
Authors (or their teams) hire marketing firms to bulk-buy their own books across multiple platforms in strategic waves. It’s coordinated. Legal. Expensive. Then what about the New York Times list? It’s editorial. That means even if you hit the sales numbers, a committee still decides whether your book “counts.”
Translation: influence and politics matter more than raw sales.
So, when someone calls themselves a #1 bestselling author, the question isn’t whether they’re lying, it’s which game they played to earn it.
Why then do I still list it? Simply because it opens doors.
In an industry obsessed with perception, certain words still carry weight--- whether or not they should. When a client sees “bestseller” in my bio, they lean in. When a speaking opportunity comes up, the title helps. When a potential ghostwriting client wants credibility, I can point to numbers and the label.
Do I wish the system was different? Absolutely.
But I’m not here to sell fairy tales. I’m here to help people write good books, make smart moves, and understand the publishing world for what it really is: a blend of truth, illusion, and strategy.
If you're a ghostwriter or author, forget the gimmicks.
What actually builds long-term credibility is writing something that changes people’s lives. Books with staying power beat launch-week noise every time. Serve your readers, and not just your ego.

If your goal is to be seen as “important,” you’ll burn out fast, but if your goal is to connect? That’s where the magic happens--- helping your clients or readers win. Whether you’re ghostwriting or publishing your own work, people remember how your words made them feel, not what list you hit.
It's knowing how to play the game without getting played. Use the tools of the trade, but don’t worship them. If “bestseller” helps get you in the room, fine, but let your actual work be the reason you stay there.
Bestseller lists are marketing tools. That’s all. Not moral validators and not quality indicators. Just one more lever in a messy machine.
So, yes, I list them. But I don’t chase them, and neither should you.
If you're serious about writing books that matter--- whether for yourself or someone else--- focus on the real stuff: craft, connection, clarity, and credibility that lasts longer than a launch window.




Comments